Mcdavid vs Makar

[Gretzky99Orr4]

Just to update. I ended up accepting the trade. Huberdeau and Makar for McDavid and Miller.
I think it helps me this season by bumping some of my weaker cats like hits and PIMS.
Now I will try and facilitate a move to get another high end D using some of my F options.

Cheers everyone!

Wow nice. You really can't go to far wrong getting McDavid.

[blayze]

If you're losing 2 keepers for 1 then I don't think it's worth it. If you're keeping Miller then it is.

McDavid is McJesus but let's not underestimate how rare a talent like Makar. I think the gap between Makar over the 2nd best Dman is greater than McDavid over the 2nd best forward in any given year.

At the same time, I think Hubie is playing over his head right now so you are selling him at his peak value. For that reason I'd pull the trigger.

edit - just read you already pulled the trigger. Good luck

[senryu]

Good work. With this kind of trade, you can't really "lose" the trade as you're getting McDavid, which is always nice. Good luck.

[CraigyB]

If you can get mcdavid you get him. Only player that has a shot at 2 ppg.

[J0e Th0rnton]

If you're losing 2 keepers for 1 then I don't think it's worth it. If you're keeping Miller then it is.

McDavid is McJesus but let's not underestimate how rare a talent like Makar. I think the gap between Makar over the 2nd best Dman is greater than McDavid over the 2nd best forward in any given year.

At the same time, I think Hubie is playing over his head right now so you are selling him at his peak value. For that reason I'd pull the trigger.

edit - just read you already pulled the trigger. Good luck

In an 11 team keep 12, there isn't a universe where Miller isn't a keeper.

Miller is a borderline keeper in a keep 5 with banger cats

[Bubba55]

Well Done!! You have improved your team and that's what it is all about.