O.E.L. vs Shattenkirk vs Kronwall

[Donglinger Jones]

Please rank the below mentioned with the the following scoring criteria (g=1.5, a=1, +/-=0.5):

Oliver Ekman-Larsson
Kevin Shattenkirk
Niklas Kronwall…

and we'll throw in Mark Giordano for good measure.

Thanks Nation!

[MarmotKing]

OEL
Shats
Kronwall

[Pengwin7]

I think +/- is a significant factor here.

Predictions:
Shattenkirk. 8G/34A/+20. 56pts.
Kronwall. 12G/30A/+6. 51pts.
OEL. 8G/38A/-4. 46pts.

See, I actually have OEL as the highest scoring... but Arizona blows. They are just a bad team.
A good defenseman on a bad team can still put up a huge minus. (Karlsson, OTT, for example)
You have to prepare for this.

I also have Kronwall as the highest goal-scorer... which one might think would give him the win with the goal bonus.

STL is so solid that Shatty's +/- should be excellent.

[Laendarian]

Shattenkirk
OEL
Kronwall

[Axeman33]

I rank them with those league settings:

OEL
Kronwall
Shattenkirk

[Fast Tony DeNiro]

For this year....Shattenkirk, OEL, Kronwall, Giordano.

Eventually....OEL, Shattenkirk, Kronwall, Giordano.

OEL has an extra gear the others don't. But Peng is correct in saying +/- is the decider for this season.