S.vatanen vs m. Reilly

[icerangers09]

hi, guys!

please, tell me what do you think who has the highest upside, and who will have more fantasy points this year and 3 years in advance

thanx, i will listen to your advices and opinions

[rainydrinkwater]

It could be wash for these guys for a while but eventually Rielly will be the superior player IMO. Whether it takes the 1-3 years as per your window, I'm not as sure, but I would go with Rielly regardless.

[agentzero]

Instinct was to say Rielly for me as well, but not by as much as one might think. Both have much to prove and I like Vatanen's team situation a little better. Rielly by only 10% for me.

[sourdough]

Vatanen owner saying Reilly.

[Zorro]

I feel Vatanen is slightly underrated and Rielly in slightly overrated..

I would probably lean towards Rielly longterm just because Vatanen is going to have to contend with Fowler and Lindholm..

[Axeman33]

I think both are still proving themselves by my gut reaction is to say Rielly.

[franklin]

For me Rielly is everything you want from Vatanen but less risky. I'd go with Rielly.

[fungchen3]

Morgan Rielly. And I'm high on both. I compare Rielly to a future Duncan Keith and Vatanen to a future Lubomir Visnovsky. Both could emerge into top offensive DMen but Rielly will be safer, more reliable and has a better chance reaching his full potential.

[VincentVega]

Reilly. I'm not buying the Vatanen hype. He is not even a guaranteed regular this year. He MIGHT get 35 points this year and he MIGHT even get to 40+ over the next couple of years but the risk with him is higher than with Reilly. Plus, Reilly's upside is higher anyway.

[Rocky71]

Reilly is Paul Coffeyesque. Dude is smooth, and would be my choice here.

[plug]

Reilly if only just for trade value... people love him, shoot for the moon with a trade offer.

[Magicstew]

Reilly for me long term, Sami Vat isn't a bad option either.

[STLblues]

Reilly for me....he has way more hype and value....get him and flip him if you want

[MillerTime89]

I love Morgan Rielly, but the Maple Leafs ruin everything they get their hands on. I'd go with Vatanen. At least the Ducks know how to run an organization.

[rainydrinkwater]

I love Morgan Rielly, but the Maple Leafs ruin everything they get their hands on. I'd go with Vatanen. At least the Ducks know how to run an organization.

Not that I would disagree with your point about the leafs asset management but Phil Kessel is a pretty good fantasy producer isn't he? The fact of the matter is that when you're good, you're good. I believe Rielly poses that type of high level skill to succeed in just about any situation.