Who to Trade?

[finminer]

Draft upcoming Sunday. Team is pretty full, but I need to promote Nichushkin, which means getting rid of someone else, or get rid of him. That also opens up a prospect slot for new kids. Which one whould you trade of these 4?
Nichushkin
Coyle
Galchenyuk
Scheifele

13 team roto keeper salary cap, 3C-2LW-2RW-2F-4D-2G-5B
Auction draft, winning bid becomes salary, $200 cap
Contracts up to 5 years, bid or entry level
FOG, FOA, DPts, Plm, SPG, SPA, GWGSOG, GAA, GNetPts, Sve%
8 man prospect roster, separate sequential draft.
Benn-Duchene-MacKinnon-Galchenyuk-Dubinsky
Saad-Nyqvist-Roussel-Scheifele-Zuccarello-Coyle
H Lindholm, McDonagh
Price, Crawford
Jones, Lehner, Nichushkin, Gormley, Jaskin, Draisaitl

[Happy Hour]

I think of these 4 I move Coyle

[RizzeeDizzee]

Keep Nichuskin, as he's the only one with superstar upside. The other three are essentially interchangeable in my mind, as well as in Dobber's Fantasy Guide, where they each have a maximum career upside in the low to mid 80s. If you put a gun to my head to make a choice, I'd say Scheifele, since he has the best "name value" not and thus would likely net you the most in return.

[Axeman33]

I'd trade Coyle from that group of 4.

As far as "superstar" upside, if a player is hitting 80+ pts in todays NHL, I'd say he's pretty darn close to a superstar. I like Scheifele and Galchenyuk more than Coyle to hit those numbers.

[Magicstew]

Auction league, so you can't get draft picks back. I would be trying to trade 2 of your keepers for a keeper upgrade (cheaper salary etc), that way you can bring Nisch up to main roster.
If stuck dropping then Coyle is your guy.

[Bass56]

Coyle is very replaceable in this format; keep Galchenyuk and Scheifele. I may have a biased opinion, but I think Galchenyuk will outproduce Nichu down the road as well, so he's the first guy I'd protect here (even though I understand you have to promote Nichushkin)

[CHunter]

I would trade Coyle

[Excelsior]

Bye bye Coyle.