Trade DILEMA??? KARMA

[dre857]

I have been offered this deal...All info in signature below:

I get: Miggy Cabrera (1B/3B), BJ Upton (OF)

I give: Prince Fielder (1B), Chone Figgins (2B/3B), Denard Span (OF)

If I were to accept...WHO SHOULD BE MY 5 KEEPERS NEXT YEAR???

KARMA will be given for best responses...

[Khanadian]

Don\'t worry about who your 5 keepers are for now, PULL THE TRIGGER!!!

Miggy, is an upgrade on Fielder and Upton I\'d sooner have than either Figgins or Span (or both for that matter).

[Khanadian]

As far as 5 keepers, the nominees could be narrowed down to:

M.Cabrera
I.Kinsler
K.Youkilis
M.Holliday
A.Soriano
N.Markakis
B.J.Upton
J.Reyes
J.Santana

Of those 9, I think you have to keep:

M.Cabrera
I.Kinsler
J.Reyes
J.Santana

So that leaves one spot for 1 of the remaining 5. This is the order I\'d consider them:

B.J.Upton
N.Markakis
K.Youkilis
A.Soriano
M.Holliday

[GoldenSeals]

In a 12 team league, you can afford to do this trade and pickup someone decent off the waiver wire. Absolutely do this deal.