cheechoo/kronwall for ryan whitney

[mclarenf1]

i\'ve been offered my cheechoo and kronwall for his ryan whitney.

its a 1 year league, do u guys think its worth it?

[rumrunner]

Whitney has something like 13 points in the last 16 games.

Is the upgrade of Whitney over Seabrook better than the difference between Cheechoo and his replacement?

[mclarenf1]

replacement for cheechoo would be
kotalik
erat
svatos
stempniak
hudler
tucker
miettinnen
zubrus
armstrong
kessel
ryder
murray
carter
blake
s. kozlov
v. kozlov
hagman
guerin
umberger
dubinsky
booth
madden
samuelsson


would the trade be worth it?

[mclarenf1]

i kept that offer open but i\'m planning to reoffer so that i either don\'t have to give up a RW or get a RW in return.

who would you guys rather have for the remainder of the year.
cammalleri or brown?

but the initial question of taking the cheechoo trade or not still stands.

thanks for the advice

[andrewklassen]

Who does Whitney bump off of your current D roster? I\'m not crazy about any of those RW replacement options. My initial thought is to keep Cheecho and find another way to upgrade your D.

P.S. I\'d rather have Cammalleri over Brown for the rest of the season.

[mclarenf1]

i hav a empty D spot right now and i have a waiver claim but its way on the bottom for brent burns. so if that goes through i would be bumping ryan whitney off my roster.

[mclarenf1]

he didn\'t take the brown offer so i\'m trying to replace cheechoo with cammalleri because i\'m stacked at LW but don\'t have very many RW, i also have a waiver claim on ryan malone cuz he was dropped for forsberg.

[mclarenf1]

mueller has just been dropped so he\'ll be available, do u think he\'d fill the hole that cheechoo leaves?