What's Carlson's value?

[rydrisc78]

I'm in a 10 team eastern conference only keeper league, with a $300 salary cap.

I have John Carlson for $19 through 2013.

I could probably land a combo of 3 of these 4 - okposo $5, little $7, marchand $7 and pacioretty $7. with an outside shot at JVR for $7.

Do I do this?

[Killer67]

We need more info about your league. Scoring set up, roster, positional eligibility, etc...

[ericdaoust]

In most formats I would keep Carlson over all of them.

[rydrisc78]

Categories are G,A, +/-, Specialty Pts (PPG, PPA, etc), TOI, and PIM

Actually, b/c of scheduling, we haven't drafted yet.

My roster, prior to selecting keepers is ($300 cap at draft)

Malkin $51
Ennis, Tyler C BUF 20
Kadri, Nazem C TOR 7
Lecavalier, Vincent C TB 36
Staal, Jordan C PIT 10
Gaborik, Marian RW NYR 37
Hartnell, Scott LW PHI 21
Kulemin, Nikolai RW TOR 15
MacArthur, Clarke LW TOR 1
Neal, James LW PIT 37
Parenteau, P.A. RW NYI 10
Semin, Alexander LW WAS 38
Versteeg, Kris RW FLA 7
Boychuk, Johnny D BOS 14
Carlson, John D WAS 19
McBain, Jamie D CAR 8
McQuaid, Adam D BOS 6
Oduya, Johnny D WPG 1
Seidenberg, Dennis D BOS 1

TG Penguins TG 25

[rydrisc78]

and there are no positional requirements just F and D.

12 F, 7 D

[hank mooney]

I'm a Carlson owner as well and am concerned about his demotion (?) off the PP units--Wideman and Hamrlik over Carlson??? Really? I thought this guy was the second coming of Mike Green, are the Caps trying to groom him to be a shutdown D guy? Tell me ain't so! Sorry to hijack this thread...