Which goalie is best keeper?

[His Dudeness]

League in my sig. I'm trading Holtby so will want to replace him with another goalie as my third goalie. Which guy is best to own? dobber rankings included:

Dubnyk: 33
Bachman 41
Curry 46
Tokarski: 49

quite a few prospect types ranked lower including:

Harding: 69
Stalock: 73
Reimer: 76

[Jurgy25]

The only goalies that have any value this year are Dubnyk and Reimer.

Overall-

Stalock- Has no value for the next few seasons, but should be the starting goalie in San Jose come 2012.
Tokarski- Future goalie in TB. Desjardins did good in limited action this year, but he isn't much of a threat to Tokarski. He is 4 years younger and has a higher ceiling than Desjardins.
Dubnyk- Some value this year, and should be the starter next year too. Olivier Roy could threaten Dubnyk in a few years, but in a few years Dubnyk could turn into a decent netminder. With a young Edmonton team though, his numbers could suffer.
Bachman- Could be a sleeper prospect pick, BUT will probably need to be traded to get any value with Campbell being the future in Dallas.
Reimer- Doing good in Toronto with limited playing time, but I don't see him having a future there. 3 headed monster (pun) forming in TOR with Gustavsson and Rynnas also looking for action.
Harding- Good backup, but nothing more. Backstrom in front, and a few good prospects in the wings= bad news for Harding.
Curry- Career Minor Leaguer in my eyes. No value.

Also may I ask who you are getting in return for Holtby. I would put Holtby #2 on this list behind Stalock, so I hope you aren't giving away Holtby because of the situation in Washington.

[His Dudeness]

Also may I ask who you are getting in return for Holtby. I would put Holtby #2 on this list behind Stalock, so I hope you aren't giving away Holtby because of the situation in Washington.

Thanks for the great input. I'm thinking of trading Holtby and Tambellini for Laich, who I see as a decent buy low. I'm leaning towards taking Dubnyk - we can only carry 3 goalies so there is an emphasis in my pool on guys who are actually playing.

[His Dudeness]

Anyone else? I need to decide in the next hour!

[Bomm Bastic]

Situationally and talent-wise I like Dubnyk and Tokarski.

EDIT: Dub has the better short term potential...imo.

[His Dudeness]

Situationally and talent-wise I like Dubnyk and Tokarski.

EDIT: Dub has the better short term potential...imo.

Thanks BB. One other goalie available is Campbell (Dallas prospect) but I think I'll stick with Dub for the short term potential.

[dyzfunctioned]

Dubnyk would be my choice. Tokarski and Campbell will be better but are further away.

[His Dudeness]

I've changed my mind and went with Campbell. I'm giving up short term value in Dubnyk for what I hope will be the best goalie available, talent wise. I've got two young starters in Halak and Quick, so I think I can afford to wait. Plus Campbell should be a good trade chip (as will Dubnyk if he takes over as starter).

But thanks for the input - rep coming once it's reloaded.

[Jurgy25]

Very good pick with Campbell over Dubnyk. Not really sold on Dub's long term potential.

[Bomm Bastic]

I've changed my mind and went with Campbell. I'm giving up short term value in Dubnyk for what I hope will be the best goalie available, talent wise. I've got two young starters in Halak and Quick, so I think I can afford to wait. Plus Campbell should be a good trade chip (as will Dubnyk if he takes over as starter).

But thanks for the input - rep coming once it's reloaded.

I like that move.