Reply With QuoteI'd keep Semin.
Gaborick or Semin....
Keeper league points only. Who would you rather have this year and in the future?
I have just been offered Gaborick for my Semin. Fair deal?
c- Tavares, Aho, Drouin ,Schenn, RNH
lw - Toffoli, Pacioretty, M. Marchment, Rust, Vatrano
rw- Ovechkin, Kucherov, Tarasenko, Duchene, Zuccarello
d- Q. Hughes, Letang, Pietrangelo, Fowler, Hanafin, Matheson
g- Rittich, Saros
I.R. Guentzel
Rookies: Kulich, Lysell, Nazar, Simashev, Mintyukov
Drop 8 players at the end of the year. No maximum/minimum games played. All players in line up every night
I'd keep Semin.
Both of these players have been streaky this season. Gaborik has 16 goals this season and 10 of them came in three games (4G game, 3G game, 3G game). I see that you are asking about points only though, and he only has 30 points on the year. Semin has been very streaky as well but has more points with 35. I would take Semin here for now and the future. He is younger as well. I'm not really a fan of Gaborik, I don't think he is all that good.
Go Jets Go
Featured Columnist for the Winnipeg Jets
http://bleacherreport.com/users/386108-anthony-capocci
Follow for Winnipeg Jets Updates
www.twitter.com/CapocciJETS
They are similar players but I would still keep Semin :P
24 team Keeper, H2H (points only), Salary cap, No Position Requirements, 12F 6D 2G
========================================
That's like asking "Left Groin or Right Groin?"
But seriously - I would take Gaborik. He's the more complete talent and #1 option on his team. The Rangers have a lot of issues to work through, but when he's on his game and healthy, he's one of the best players in the game.
16-team H2H Dynasty
G,A,+/-,PPP,PIM,SOG,W,GAA,SV%,SHO
3C - Roy, Berglund, Horcoff, Gerbe, Adam,
3LW - Sedin, Comeau, Dubinsky, Comeau, Foligno
3RW - Hemsky, Grabner, Hudler, Boyes
6D - Boyle, Shattenkirk, McBain, Gilbert, Demers, Russell, Coburn, Spurgeon
IR - Crosby, Regin, McDonald
1G - Ward, Dubnyk, Elliot
Farm:
C - Bjugstad, Perreault
LW - Bowman, Bartschi
RW - Machacek, Repik, Noesen, Ritchie, Catenacci
D - Gustafsson, Klefbom
G - Bachman, Greiss, Karlsson, Lindback
I would keep Semin as well, similar upside, younger, less full seasons lost to injury.
16 Team 4th Year H2H Yahoo! Keeper League, 2012 Champion
Keep 8 (Max 1 Goalie) + 2* (23 and under)
G,A,+/-,PIM,PPP,SOG,FW,HIT,BLK,W,GAA,SV,SV%
2LW,3C,2RW,3D,1U,2G,8BN,3IR
LW Landeskog*, C Tavares*,Getzlaf, RW Ovechkin,Malkin(C),Seguin*(C),D Subban,G Lundqvist, Lehner*
Draft - 1st,2 2nds, 2 3rds.
Yeah, but on the other hand, Gaborik's injury problems were supposed to be fixed by those surgeries. Semin just seems to have these nickel and dime injuries all the time.Originally Posted by You Know
Not saying I necessarily believe that, just throwing it out there.
I honestly don't know about this one. I think if Gabby was having a better season I'd come down on his side. Semin will likely be leaving Washington. That could be good or bad for him.
RETIRED
Posting Permissions
