Giordano or Kronwall ?

[AFlyers66]

Who has more upside in roto keeper in my siggy below :

Giordano or Kronwall ?

Kronwall's 2 goals last night came out of left field....he'd done zippo all season so far.

[Pengwin7]

Giordano is the better overall defenseman. His improvement makes him a candidate for more & more PP time with PHI.

However, keep your ear out for "Lidstom-retirement" talk and jump on Kronwall (esp. in your deep 17 player keeper) as soon as it seems realistic.

[Rocky71]

I'd feel more comfortable with Kronwall, especially if he plays anywhere close to 82 games. I like Giordano, but he plays on an inconsistant team that has struggled to put up points thus far. With Rafalski out, Kronwall should get is share of premium minutes, and his production will go up accordingly.

[NoWayOut]

I'd feel more comfortable with Kronwall, especially if he plays anywhere close to 82 games. I like Giordano, but he plays on an inconsistant team that has struggled to put up points thus far. With Rafalski out, Kronwall should get is share of premium minutes, and his production will go up accordingly.

I'd add that with that offense, even with Rafalski back there'll still be plenty of wealth to spread around. I'd take Kronwall as well.

[dyzfunctioned]

Rather have Gio. Seeing good minutes on the PP, is only getting better and gets a ton of PIM.

[garethbush]

The moment Lidstrom retires Kronwall's value will skyrocket. Still pissed Lids came back this year.