marleau or Langkow for Campbell or Whitney(Ryan)

[leafnation]

Which if either of these makes sense. I am the one with marleau and Langkow and need D help.

[shallowfrozenwater]

Marleau for Campbell is the only deal that i think has a chance to make sense for me. Langkow will outscore the rest and Campbell is the amongst the best scoring options on D so if you can get Campbell for Marleau then you may be overpaying a little but i still say it\'ll be worth given your team needs.

[leafnation]

thanks,
Now, i just got offered Chara for Marleau. Would you rather have Chara or Campbell. Chara will give good +- and PIMs with less points.

[shallowfrozenwater]

you assess this correctly so the guy i\'d want would depend on what i needed. if i need PIMs and pts combined together then i want Chara but if i have a bigger need for pts alone, particularly PPP then i want Campbell.

[leafnation]

thanks, i\'m going to go ahead and do it for Chara, I seem to be close in PIMS and +- categories every week.