OK which deal would you do?

[sensfan19]

Ok I am going to over pay for a player or multiple players, here are the trade options. which would you do?

A)

Vanek
Boyes
Savard
Krejci
early pick upgrade

for

Heatley
M.Richards


B)

Vanek
Boyes
Savard
Krejci
early pick upgrade

for

Getzlaf
B.Ryan


C)

Boyes
Giroux
Krejci
early pick upgrade

for

P.Kane



What would you do?

[lainlin2]

I wouldn't do any of these.

[Shake]

Ok I am going to over pay for a player or multiple players, here are the trade options. which would you do?

A)

Vanek
Boyes
Savard
Krejci
early pick upgrade

for

Heatley
M.Richards


B)

Vanek
Boyes
Savard
Krejci
early pick upgrade

for

Getzlaf
B.Ryan


C)

Boyes
Giroux
Krejci
early pick upgrade

for

P.Kane



What would you do?

I would NOT do any of these overpay trades. HOWEVER if this is something you are going to do regardless, I like Getzlaf / Ryan - but again, I would not do these trades.

[Shoeless]

I actually think deal A is the best of the lot but I think we discussed this one in another thread and I am not sure I would do it either.

[sensfan19]

I canceled them I need to think.

The crappy part is 2 of the GMs will not accept fair trades they must be overpaid if I want to trade.

I'll sit back and think for a bit.

Would

Savard and Boyes

for

Perry

be ok?

[Dennis4022]

I canceled them I need to think.

The crappy part is 2 of the GMs will not accept fair trades they must be overpaid if I want to trade.

I'll sit back and think for a bit.

Would

Savard and Boyes

for

Perry

be ok?

no it wouldn´t be okay.

just a question: Who forces you to trade with the gms who don´t accept fair offers?

You should trade to improve your team, not just to have done it!

[sensfan19]

yeah well they have the only players I am interested in. The other managers who I have tried to over pay for Ovie, Crosby, Malkin etc dont want to deal so I guess I am trading for the sake of trading.

I'll lay low for a couple weeks. I'll see what comes my way. Thanks for the comments it prob stopped me from doing something dumb.

[Dennis4022]

The other managers who I have tried to over pay for Ovie, Crosby, Malkin etc dont want to deal so I guess I am trading for the sake of trading.

this will bring you the players you want and some 5th and 6th places for the next couple of years. If that´s what you want, you are on the right track!