Quick Help Needed ! - Which side would you take?

[sixhands]

I did have this posted in the trade section but I am kinda running out of time
And I forgot to check mark the "Don't show signature box"

Hey folks,

Dynasty keeper league
Points as follows G/A/PPG/SHG/GWG
Positional requirements 2C/2L/2R/4D/3U
Daily roster changes

Which side would you take?

A) Anze Kopitar - TJ Oshie - Jack Johnson - 11th overall 2009 pick

or

B) Patrick Sharp - Nathan Horton - Mike Green

Cheers

[Keeperkiller]

Option B, I think it'll pay off short term and in the long term. Just having Green would make any team better as his upside is considerably higher than JJ to date.

[ross10019]

Option B for sure. Mainly because of the impact of Mike Green, but I am also a big believer in Horton becoming the 85+ point player that justifies the Panthers drafting him 3rd overall in that deep draft.

[MacLiii]

I think it's almost a toss up and depends on the talent level in the draft.

There is no question that Green is the best player in either Segment and his points as a "D" are huge and JJ will IMO never reach that level. The issue is that Kopitar is the next best player, Oshie is working his way up to the star status and the 11th pick could be huge depending on who you're ablt to snag.

Horton is Very good and Sharp is underated but a little older.

For the here and now, I think the Green, Horton and Sharp is the better choice. A few years from now, I think that the Kopitar, JJ, Oshie and the 11th Pick might actually be better.

[Dennis4022]

I´d take side B.

4 of the 5 scoring categories are for goals only, that increases Sharp´s, Horton´s and Green´s value a lot.

Side A is heavier on assits, and as they aren´t very valuable in your pool, i´d prefer B very clear!

[sixhands]

Thank you very much folks, always appreciate the insight.

I didn't want to "miss" something just because Green was involved.

Thanks again.

[Chadosaur]

Well, if I knew that the Dobber faithful thought I had you beat, I would have just done it

But seriously, considering the growth curve for Kopistar, Oshie & JJ, I'm still on the fence about the whole thing.

[akakak]

if youre and in a league where you keep a lot of players, and are rebuilding, than option A is a very good offer. But without knowing your situation, Option B is going to be everybody's choice.

[sixhands]

Well, if I knew that the Dobber faithful thought I had you beat, I would have just done it

But seriously, considering the growth curve for Kopistar, Oshie & JJ, I'm still on the fence about the whole thing.

LOL, thank you for being on the fence