Judge this trade in keeper league

[coldsquad2002]

I just traded Ladislav Nagy, Patrick O\'Sullivan, Brendan Shanahan and Andrew Brunette all for Jaromir Jagr.

[ddp]

The guy who gave up Jagr got hosed. All of those players are not star players. The better player in the deal always wins.

[Chadosaur]

Unless the guy who gave up Jagr has a bunch of bums for the remainder of his roster, he got worked. If the rest of his roster sucks, I can see making this move to fill it out.

Shanahan is solid but declining. Brunette is solid, but not a star. Nagy is a gamble at best. O\'Sullivan may turn out excellent, but it\'ll take awhile. With Jagr, you get proven scoring power, and a guy who will still push 100 points for a couple years to come.

[TheHammer24]

I mean, yeah, it appears the Jagr side won. I guess we have to consider how deep the rosters were and what his needs were.

[Shoeless]

I would be more interested in seeing your team and league set up to evaluate this. His team and needs are irrelevant - this is about your team. Jagr isn\'t that far from retirement and I would be concerned you really have left yourself short on keeper assets - those same guys might have been parlayed into more keeper value even if less short term production.

I certainly don\'t have trouble with who you let go to get you did though. I only wonder if you could have got more.