Heatley for Thornton and Tanguay

[Courtnall]

Would you guys do this deal?

I get: J.Thornton and Tanguay
I give: Heatley

RW: Heatley, Radulov, Michalek
C: Datsyuk, Roy, Legwand, Bouchard
LW: Semin, Parise(LW,C) D.Brown Carcillo

It would leave me short on quality at RW but I`d hope to make a new deal with my added depth at centre to get a decent RW. Opinions!!!

[Capn Jimmy]

I think you should make this deal. I definitely feel that you are winning it (assuming straight points?). You do put yourself in a hole at RW, so how good this deal is also depends on how quickly you can fill that hole.

[Courtnall]

sorry forgot to add that it`s a yahoo pool and the categories are

G A Pts PIM PPP */- GWG SOG

[Sharpie]

You will lose a lot of G and SOG in this trade, but if you can turn around and trade a C for a goal scoring RW that would be pretty huge. I think I would take this deal and look for a RW of say Gaborik\'s stature for a C like Roy.