Trade Clayton Keller for Rielly Smith?

[tarheel]

I have been offered Rielly Smith and a late first round pick for Clayton Keller. This is a 12 team Dynasty League.

Should I pull the trigger?

[PicklePickle]

I would not

[Doug Glatt]

I would probably do it. When was the last time one of Arizona's F draft picks developed into anything while in that organization? Vegas will be really good. Reilly is decent enough of a replacement for now. If you are good at drafting you will get a nice player there.

[zambronies]

Keep what you have

[tarheel]

Forgot to mention its a salary cap league and Keller is slated to make 7.1M for 8 years. Does that change anything?

[Bobby4Ever]

sure Smith is a better value now but in a couple of years as a FA he may get what Keller is getting or close to it. Keller being a lot younger has more upside i think and will be a lock on PP1 while Smith I think is PP2. If you can fit Keller with no cap issues I say keep him but that pick could get me thinking depending on what the rest of your roster looks like. Young or mostly vets?

[zambronies]

Agee with the above. If you have the room, keep keller.

[Luffy D Monkey]

Kind of depends what you think you can get with the pick.
I like Keller a lot more than Smith and I think you'd be selling a bit low right now.

[stevegamer]

I think that I'd be able to make that deal work by drafting well, but who is out there that you might get?