Semin/Pitkanen for E.Staal/Green

[rumrunner]

Easy question... which side wins?

points only scoing system g=a=1

[hagarty]

I don\'t think this is an easy question at all...you trade the rear guard of one PP for the other...and the best player (staal) off one team for the other\'s 2nd best in Semin. Staal is sucking (right now) but is just as much a stud as semin is.... coupled with staal struggling is semin\'s bandaid status..and future risk aswell. Green\'s shoulder injury is bothersome... but personally without looking at the numbers I think it\'s an easy choice which side I would rather have...but the numbers might justify it the other way. I take the Green Staal side every time.... it\'s your keeper league from sig I assume...so I jump on the deal myself...this year might be a wash...but staal putting up 100 again isn\'t a stretch...and green playing with OV next year when 100% all year (I hope)...no contest who I want... I\'d Act fast

[SeaDawg]

Staal/Green by quite a bit, IMO.

I prefer Staal over Semin because of Semin\'s injury history and, quite frankly, I just think Staal is a better player who is (admittedly) slumping, but is still young and full of potential.

In my view, Green is so far ahead of Pitkanen that it isn\'t even worth listing all the reasons why.

[Anonymous]

You\'re trading one indefinitely injured player for another, but in my opinion Green will be back first.

Staal is better than Semin, or will be by the time he returns from injury. Green is better than Pitkanen, who probably will be injured by the time Green gets back. The Staal and Green side wins for me because that side get the two better players and the two less injury prone players.

[PatInTheHat]

Staal/Green. Not close.