Atkinson vs Nuge

[TheRookie]

Who?s going to be more productive.

[JHouly]

Nuge for me

[lucafen4]

Nuuuuuuuuuuuuge

[Wonko]

I think The Nuge is gonna stick with Mcdavid. They work brilliantly together offensively and defensively. Whomever they throw on RW will reap the rewards (right now Rattie).

So, yeah Nuge. I see him going 70+.

[Joker]

Nuge

[dino_2000_22]

Nuge is the only guy that can come close to matching McJesus' speed he will be on his wing...therefore he is almost handed 70 points

[niconasr]

In my own personal rankings, I have Atkinson for 62 and Nuge for 61. So......I guess it comes down to personal preference. I do believe Nugent-Hopkins has higher upside being on the same team and hopefully same line as McDavid so I would choose him.

[TheRookie]

Thanks everyone for your opinions. Rep given to all who replied.

[MZac]

Nuge just has more upside with McDavid as his potential C. I don't see Atkinson going more than 60-65 (absolute tops) and Nuge can do that without McDavid. Nuge is the easy pick here for me.

[hockeyrobot]

I prefer Atkinson here. Don't like relying on the linemate to do the work and do not think RNH can hit 60 without McDavid.

[Wonko]

I prefer Atkinson here. Don't like relying on the linemate to do the work and do not think RNH can hit 60 without McDavid.

If RNH stays on PP 1 I think he can hit 60 even without spending the entire season on Mcdavid's line.

[Dover]

They both depends on their super linemates (McDavid/Panarin) but I’ll give a slight advantage to RNH.

[chuckcouples]

In my own personal rankings, I have Atkinson for 62 and Nuge for 61. So......I guess it comes down to personal preference. I do believe Nugent-Hopkins has higher upside being on the same team and hopefully same line as McDavid so I would choose him.

If you don't believe YOUR OWN rankings, you should probably redo them!

Another vote for Baby Nuge.