Is this lopsided or fair trade?

[mike hall]

Trading Mackinnon & Kreider for Tavares & Point? (my plan is to drop Point and pick up Nico Hischier off waivers) My approach is 2 for 1 to the other GM but i wanted to ask is this fair value for Tavares or would it be considered lopsided for the other GMs

League is this year only no keepers.

Also.... Niederreiter was just dropped, would it be worth picking him up and dropping horvat or Mantha?

Thanks in advance.

[JRA]

trade is fair.............Take Tavares and Nino..... thats incredible value

[Fighting_Emu]

yea its a good trade if you can get Nino in a one year...

[tweetdrivr]

All good advice and I too like you getting Tavares and Nino N. Even more so in a 1 yr. Do it.

[HRM Fantasy Fan]

This is lopsided in my opinion. I wouldn't consider this if I was the owner Tavares.

[butch]

I might be alone in this opinion but I'm not sure if I'd drop Point in order to add either nino or nico in a one year league if said trade went through .

At some point , maybe streaming in and out of b.point >>> someone like nino/nico with a better schedule makes sense though .

[mike hall]

I might be alone in this opinion but I'm not sure if I'd drop Point in order to add either nino or nico in a one year league if said trade went through .

At some point , maybe streaming in and out of b.point >>> someone like nino/nico with a better schedule makes sense though .

My second point was should I drop Anthony mantha and pick up nino niederreitor?

[butch]

My second point was should I drop Anthony mantha and pick up nino niederreitor?

nino is probably safer bet to get his 5o points but it could also be mantha's coming out party.

[mike hall]

nino is probably safer bet to get his 5o points but it could also be mantha's coming out party.

I ended up dropping spezza for nino kept mantha.

[The Black Panther]

This is lopsided in my opinion. I wouldn't consider this if I was the owner Tavares.

Definitely AGREE. NOT EVEN CLOSE

[rangerdanger]

I definitely think the Tavares and Nino side wins in this deal. I don't think MacKinnon is going to be quite as good a player as many hoped. He can st ill be very giood. I just don't think as good as most had had projected.