Rank these defenders please

[mogilny]

Please help me out in deciding which defenders to pick up. Need two based on these score values:

Points league: G(3), A(2), +/-(0.1), PIM (0.5), PPP(1), SHP(2), Hits (0.2), Shots (0.1), GWG (1.5)

Available:

Del Zotto
Myers
Nurse
Savard
J. Johnson
Franson
Stone
Campbell
Orpik

[GTA Fan]

If someone scores a PPG they are earning G (3) + PPP (1) + SOG (0.1), and potentially GWG (1.5), but we have no way of using that particular stat to our advantage, so it will be ignored. Replace PPG for +/- if it's an even strength goal. All of this means you need a shooter.

Because SHP/GWG are weighted so heavily it makes things pretty random. It does rule out Orpik, who won't be getting much points of any kind.

Stone, Savard, Franson are the guys you need to look at, imo. I don't think it matters which one. They will all kill your plus/minus shoot the puck, hit above average, and fight for PP1 roles.

[mogilny]

If someone scores a PPG they are earning G (3) + PPP (1) + SOG (0.1), and potentially GWG (1.5), but we have no way of using that particular stat to our advantage, so it will be ignored. Replace PPG for +/- if it's an even strength goal. All of this means you need a shooter.

Because SHP/GWG are weighted so heavily it makes things pretty random. It does rule out Orpik, who won't be getting much points of any kind.

Stone, Savard, Franson are the guys you need to look at, imo. I don't think it matters which one. They will all kill your plus/minus shoot the puck, hit above average, and fight for PP1 roles.

cheers thank for the insight.

I'm wondering if I should just add Savard and Johnson and just bank on the jackets turning it up

[Gosens]

Savard and Johnson seem to be the best bet, 1st D line for CBJ who is coached by someone who believes running offence through his D. Otherwise Stone will probably get points by being OEL partner.

[rangerfan2430]

Ya either Savard or Johnson would be best