Help! Who would you Pick

[edthebum]

Hi, I have to pick between,1#(Luonge Lupul and Naslund) and 2#(Morrow Huselius and Alfredsson). Which would you pick? And, is it close? Keeping in mind we get 1point for goals and assists, .2 for a PIM and goalies get 2points for win, 1point for shootout lose and 2points for shut-out.
Thanks ED

[nyrhockey28]

Luongo and Alfredsson

[habsrule]

Luongo and Alfie, only other possibility is Morrow because of Pims...

[Ari]

Assuming you\'re choosing between 2 packages, I go with #2, Morrow and Alffy are 2 big players vs. 1 in Luongo (who\'s only slightly better with this system)

[Bass56]

Well I know who I would pick, but let\'s just see what each guy would get with your stat categories and an approximation of their performance this year:

1.1 Luongo 35 wins- 20 loses- 15 otl- 6SO = 97pts
1.2 Lupul 25 goals- 35 assists- 50 Pims = 70pts
1.3 Naslund 25 goals- 40 assists- 60 Pims = 77pts

Luongo is the clear winner and I underevaluated his upcoming season...


2.1 Morrow 32 goals- 43 assists- 100 Pims = 95pts
2.2 Huselius 25 goals- 45 assists- 45 Pims = 79pts
2.3 Alfreds. 40 goals- 45 assists- 40 Pims = 93pts

The clear winner here is harder to point out. I was maybe a bit generous with the 75 point prediction to Morrow, but I think Dallas will be strong this year and he will be leading them. On the other hand, Alfredsson is going to be playing on a different team (yes still the Sens, but we all know how much they have changed in contrast to last year). I see his production dropping slightly, also considering he is not 100% after his late-season injuries...

I would go with Luongo (no doubt) and Morrow, but with Alfie being a very close second to Morrow (flip a coin if you need to).

Good luck!

Edit:
WAIT!!! I just re-read your message and I think you are debating between PACKAGE 1 and PACKAGE 2, rather than one player in each one. If that\'s the case, with my approximations, package 1 (Luongo, Lupul, Naslund) gets you 244pts. Package 2 (Morrow, Huselius, Alfredsson) gets you 267pts. Even is these numbers were based on estimates, I would still believe that package 2 is the better one of the 2.