A couple of trade options ... Opinions Appreciated

[ixhuntaxi]

Folks, first and foremost thanks for looking at my thread.

Please have a look at my sig for my team, but I am in a weekly 10 team H2H, G A +/- SOG PPP HITS PIMS.
I have one trade that has been offered to me and one trade that I would like to offer.

1)The trade that has been offered to me was for me to give up Quick for Nash straight up. Thoughts? My remaining goalies are Rinne and Holtby

2)The trade that I am thinking of offering is me giving up Holtby and either Lehtera/Oshie/Backes/Gabby for Niemi and either Thornton, Hartnell or Foligno.

Please let me know your thoughts and particularly in trade #2 if and who I should offer up.

[Sulla]

1) no chance... weekly starts (how many at each position?) and you are trading a stud for a forward shooting a 20% so chance of regression
2) I'm not the biggest Niemi fan (I think he is lucky Stalock got injured when he did) but I understand the logic here. Thornton would be my forward of choice for one of your forwards but I'm not sure I would do this either

[snipshow101]

1)The trade that has been offered to me was for me to give up Quick for Nash straight up. Thoughts? My remaining goalies are Rinne and Holtby

2)The trade that I am thinking of offering is me giving up Holtby and either Lehtera/Oshie/Backes/Gabby for Niemi and either Thornton, Hartnell or Foligno.

1) Terrible for you
2) Terrible for him

[GoNucks]

He is trying to capitalize on Nashs hot start....no chance I would consider that deal.

I also don't like the basis of trade #2.With Trotz in Wash I really like Holtby over Niemi. Also Holtby has no competition whereas Niemi has Stalock breathing down his neck.

I wouldnt see the downgrade in goal be worth the small upgrade upfront.

[ixhuntaxi]

Thank u gents for all the feedback