Neal vs. Nash

[Yardsale]

Who would you rather keep?

Cats in sig.

Lol, last year this wouldn't have been a question.

[rainydrinkwater]

I'm not going to let the past three weeks influence what has been evident for the past three years. Neal is my guy here.

[skiteam14]

I'm not going to let the past three weeks influence what has been evident for the past three years. Neal is my guy here.

Agreed, I think Neal is actually shooting more than Nash. Nash has an inflated shooting percentage right now and even though Stepan's return should help him, it looks like Neal is providing more hits.

[Rehdaun]

I guess it can't be both. I want to say Neal but have to say Nash. Neal's historical offensive stats are inflated based on who he played with in PIT. I'm not convinced that those will be as high in NSH. Nash has proven that he can can sustain that no matter where he plays. I'm ignoring last years stats for Nash. He wasn't the same player after his concussion. He was playing more on the outside and seemed to be afraid to go inside. The offseason seems to have done him some good.

[Canucks_fan18]

If you don't have decide now then I wouldn't worry about it. I think what Nash showed in the lockout season 42 points in 44 games is closer to what he is then last year. However the big question mark is what Neal showed in Dallas or Pitt his true self? I think Nash will be a 68-72 point guy with 30-35 goals, I am not sure about Neal, he could be the second coming of Jeff Carter tons of goals not allot of apples clip 40 but only throw in 20-25 apples.

If you can wait and see.