Gardiner vs. Faulk

[RookieInsider]

Who has the better upside? Who will be better on their respective teams points wide? Who will be better multi-cat wise? I want to get a feel for who is a better player all around

[havanablast21]

I'll take Gardiner. Just cause. I don't trust Faulk esp with the uncertainty in Carolina. It may be close but Gardiner is my pick.

[FinnishFlash]

I take Gardiner as well. Although I think Faulk will be the best "real NHL" D-Man, I see him topping out around 35 ish points, I think Gardiner has a higher ceiling.

[RookieInsider]

Thanks for the insight guys, greatly appreciated

[vangregs]

Gardiner. He's gonna be elite.

[Zorro]

I like Gardiner aswell over Faulk..

Better NHL dman: Faulk.. Better fantasy dman: Gardiner..

[mounD]

I still have very, very high hopes for the offensive upside of Jake Gardiner. Faulk is the better real-life NHLer, but in terms of fantasy upside it's gotta be Gardiner imo.

[plug]

Another one for Gardiner.

[als_revenge]

Gardiner. He's gonna be elite.

Elite? I'm not so sure about that...

In terms of multi-category, they were pretty much dead-even last year. But Faulk had a better situation; for that reason, I'd lean to Gardiner.