You rank them, you get karma

[rufio.85]

Hey guys,
our redraft is coming up in a week... Only 4 goalies will need to be drafted.
I'm one of the four GM's who will pick one. These are the most notable left-overs:

Holtby
Ward
Pavelec
Dubnyk
Nabokov
Varlamov

Now, I don't think Holtby will be available when my turn comes, as I don't have picks in the first and the second rounds... So, how would you rank these goalies? I have a shot at first position, points only league, wins and shutouts count.

[The Bottlenecker]

Holtby garnered the 2nd most points by a goaltender in my league last year (see signature to see how), and as such he is the no brainer first netminder to choose from the list you supplied. However, if you think he will be gone by the time you pick, I would grab either Pavelec or Dubnyk as you know they are going to get lots of playing time/starts and are still young enough to iniatiate trade talk with other GM's if they get hot and you still believe that you need an upgrade in the goal. I just cannot believe you'll get the same interest (or return) if you grab the 100 year old Nabokov or Carolina's Band-Aid boy, Ward.

[One87]

Hey guys,
our redraft is coming up in a week... Only 4 goalies will need to be drafted.
I'm one of the four GM's who will pick one. These are the most notable left-overs:

Holtby
Ward
Pavelec
Dubnyk
Nabokov
Varlamov

Now, I don't think Holtby will be available when my turn comes, as I don't have picks in the first and the second rounds... So, how would you rank these goalies? I have a shot at first position, points only league, wins and shutouts count.

Ward
Holtby
Pavelec

Dubnyk

Varlamov
Nabokov

[theslymonkey]

Holtby
Ward
Pavelec
Dubnyk
Nabokov
Varlamov

I would love to offer some rankings that will blow your mind. But you already have them ranked correctly.

But I will take my Karma. Thanks

[Bubba55]

My 2 Cents:

Holtby

Pavelec
Ward

Dubnyk
Nabokov
Varlamov

[rufio.85]

I would love to offer some rankings that will blow your mind. But you already have them ranked correctly.

But I will take my Karma. Thanks

Haha take all of it Sly!

[uofmehockey]

Ward
Holtby
Pavelec

Dubnyk

Varlamov
Nabokov

I concur with this.

[AFlyers66]

I rank 'em:

Holtby

Dubnyk

Ward
Pavelec

Nabokov
Varlamov

As a Holtby owner, can't recommend him enough if you can somehow make it work. Having said that, I'm gonna split with others here, as I'm very high on Dubnyk. He's got peace of mind as the undisputed starter, and this collection of amazing young talent HAS to take that leap forward soon. Right? Right?! I see good things for Dub this season; he's one of my sleepers.

Good luck, let us know what happens!