more context would help
which one would you pick in a keeper. chara is better for now by far but edler is very young
keeper league rotisserie and pts are
goals, assista. pts, plus/ minus, pims, ppp, shp, gwg
goalie pts- wins, g.a., g.a.a., sa, sv, sv%, so
players are
c- j.benn, tavares,h.sedin, d.stepan,
rw- ,perry, e.malkin, d, byfuglien, t.toffoli
lw- d.sedin, e.kane, m.lucic, l.couture
d-men- yandle, fowler, oel, d.doughty, t.enstrom ,m.rielly j.trouba, h.lindholm
g- a.niemi, m.a.fleury, s.bobrovsky, j.markstrom,
you get to keep everyone and dress 3 per forward position and 2 utility as well as 5 d-men. 82 games for each spot
more context would help
which guy would you take in a full keeper and my sig below
keeper league rotisserie and pts are
goals, assista. pts, plus/ minus, pims, ppp, shp, gwg
goalie pts- wins, g.a., g.a.a., sa, sv, sv%, so
players are
c- j.benn, tavares,h.sedin, d.stepan,
rw- ,perry, e.malkin, d, byfuglien, t.toffoli
lw- d.sedin, e.kane, m.lucic, l.couture
d-men- yandle, fowler, oel, d.doughty, t.enstrom ,m.rielly j.trouba, h.lindholm
g- a.niemi, m.a.fleury, s.bobrovsky, j.markstrom,
you get to keep everyone and dress 3 per forward position and 2 utility as well as 5 d-men. 82 games for each spot
with your team leaning more towards the younger players i would probably go with edler
I've been tricked on these ones before.
Extended CATS - Chara (Edler's not bad though)
Cap - Edler. (crucifies Chara)
Points - Edler
Consistency - hmmm. Chara has the better long term track record, but he's old and not the classic 'easy skater' that often ages so gracefully (see Lidstrom, Selanne, Sakic...)
Age - Edler
Now, that age thing... some of the classic old D-men just keep going & going & going. So I'm not so sure that Chara will have a 'dramatic' drop off any time soon. Boston also isn't too busy striving to get some whiz jack PP QB.
I have Edler and think he's great. Sometimes we see our Edler's (young D-men) take dramatic and unexpected drop offs. No reason to think this is going to happen at this moment. Vancouver looks pretty dandy... but it has happened before.