Here are those 2 QBs weekly record compared to Manning
- Rivers: 9.6, 15, -0.5, 9.2, 9.9, 0.0, bye, 2.9
- Cutler: 13.9, -5.7, 2.4, 12.9, 16.5, bye, 7.2, -2
- Manning: 15.6, 1.9, 15.3, 23.4, 20.3, bye, 20.5
If you mixed and matched QBs, the absolute BEST you could have done is 70.8 vs Manning's 120. Plus you'd be a psychic that wins millions in Las Vegas betting on NFL.
Upcoming schedules
Rivers - TB, DEN, BAL, CIN, PIT, CAR, NYJ, OAK
Cutler - TEN, HOU, SF, MIN, SEA, MIN, GB, ARI, DET
Manning - CIN, CAR, SD, KC, TB, OAK, BAL, CLE, KC
It's alot easier to pick up a scrub RB/WR (Hillis & Britt 2 yrs ago, D.Murray & L.Robinson last year) that suddenly surprises and gets hot versus a QB.
I would consider the trade based on best players versus each other, not positional
- Manning (120) > McGahee (95)
- Turner (74) = or > A. Johnson (63)
- Cutler (45) = Britt (30)
- CHI def (93) > MIN def (67)
I've won exactly 50% of my hockey and football pools (not counting finishing 2nd or 3rd).
This year I autodrafted a NFL team that was projected on yahoo to finish last, but i'm tied for 3rd best record, despite having watched "part" of 1 NFL game this whole year (i'm here in australia for a year where games play at 3 am or during my working hours)
http://profiles.sports.yahoo.com/use...H6M6RXJ54MXGB4
Yet I don't consider myself a fantasy genius/expert.
I'd still listen to the schmuck (Barnwell) who gets paid for a living based on NFL and watches ALL the NFL games each week.