Who Should Stay... Who Should Go

[Les_Glorieux]

16 teams, start 12 F, 8 D, 2 G, roto, no playoffs, 6 keepers G/A/+-/PIM/Sv/W/GAA

How would you rank the following d-men for keeper potential.

Enstrom
Weber
Keith
Carlson
Lidstrom
Boyle
Myers

[Carcillo]

Weber - Beast, although not having a great season so far this year
Keith - elite D-man
Boyle - elite D-man but not as good keeper D-man as Weber and Keith are because of his age
Myers - having a rough season but showed flashes of brilliance last year; great future ahead of him and very good keeper D-man
Enstrom - very good D-man but gets mostly assists and not many PIM; +/- isn't very good either
Carlson - not as proven as the others and has Green ahead of him in depth charts; like Enstrom gets mostly assists and not that many goals
Lidstrom - still elite D-man but don't have much left in him

[dyzfunctioned]

Keith - Best on the list, hands down.
Lidstrom - one of the best on the list but could be last season.
Weber/Boyle - Both great, Weber will have less A and worse +/- but is younger, gets more G, and gets more PIM
Enstrom
Carlson
Myers

So going for the win this year, I'd take Keith, Lidstrom, Boyle, Weber, Enstrom, Carlson, Myers in that order.

Aiming for the future, Keith, Weber, Carlson, Enstrom, Boyle, Myers, Lidstrom in that order.

Overall I'd probably rank them - Keith, Boyle, Weber, Lidstrom, Enstrom, Carlson, Myers

[Jack da Rippa]

Keith

Weber
Lidstrom
Boyle
Enstrom
Myers
Carlson

[Sin Bin]

Keith
Weber
Boyle
Carlson
Enstrom
Myers
Lidstrom