the price for bogosian....yandle?

[kiran]

Hi All,

how many of you would consider it?
i have yandle and was offered bogosian on a 1 for 1 trade.
pts only dfull keeper league.

thanks for answering as i really like bogo but am seriously thinking it's too high a price to pay

[vozzy81]

Hi All,

how many of you would consider it?
i have yandle and was offered bogosian on a 1 for 1 trade.
pts only dfull keeper league.

thanks for answering as i really like bogo but am seriously thinking it's too high a price to pay

i'd keep yandle in this situation....however i notice you have OEL on your blueline...it might be nice to have studs on different teams in the future. If this were me tho i would keep yandle.
good luck!

[slufoot]

Pts only I like Yandle more, roto I like Bogosian. VERY even IMO though. The one thing Bogosian has going for him in Atlanta though is a guaranteed 1PP job. Yandle still isn't consistently playing 1PP (even though he produces) and has Ekman-Larsson, Jovanovski, Aucoin to compete with now and Goncharov, Ross, Gormley in the pipeline.

[Instant Karma]

I'd keep Yandle too. He's having a slow start, but I'm pretty sure he's the real deal. Bogo, can't get a good read.

[Brady19]

Pts only I like Yandle more, roto I like Bogosian. VERY even IMO though. The one thing Bogosian has going for him in Atlanta though is a guaranteed 1PP job. Yandle still isn't consistently playing 1PP (even though he produces) and has Ekman-Larsson, Jovanovski, Aucoin to compete with now and Goncharov, Ross, Gormley in the pipeline.

Uhh, I bet Enstrom and his 50 points last season and his 7pts in 8 games this year would disagree that Bogosian has a guarenteed job as the PP QB in Atlanta.

Even Byfuglien I think has more short term value than Bogosian.

[Shake]

Hi All,

how many of you would consider it?
i have yandle and was offered bogosian on a 1 for 1 trade.
pts only dfull keeper league.

thanks for answering as i really like bogo but am seriously thinking it's too high a price to pay

Stick with Yandle....Bogo needs to show more before I'd move Yandle for him.

[ridinryan44]

Yup, Yandle here. Bogo has big upside and big goal potential, but has thus far been injury prone and only shown flashes of his ability. Yandle has been much more consistent. If someone wants Yandle and is offering Bogo... ask him to add something in... see if you can sweeten the deal to make it worth it as I think both have great potential.

[SavageGardener]

Yandle is a great young defenceman in his own right, and Bogo is way too injury prone so far in his career. Keep Yandle.

[veronesepk]

Yandle > Bogo. Byfuglien and Enstrom are running things in ATL.

[One Man Wolf Pack]

Bogosian is a "buy low" right now given the early season injury and thus slow/non existent start. he will however be someone of value once he gets back in games. that being said Yandle is too much to give up for him now. i like the idea of going after Bogo (the old buy low/sell high mantra) so getting him is a good thing but the price has to be right....Yandle is not right!

can you counter with someone of lesser value or a combo of players and/or picks?

[dodospice]

Keep Yandle....Bogosian will be at about the same level as Yandle when alls said and done but Yandle will outpoint him for the next little while.Phoenix's best defenceman is Yandle soon it will be Ekman-Larsson,Yandle or Gormely but until that time they will ride Yandle like a pack mule.
Keep the workhorse.