A little keeper help for a 1yr guy, plz!

[Gern Blansten]

Background
Keep 4/H2H/Yahoo
C, C, LW, LW, RW, RW, D, D, D, D, UTIL, G, G
3 G starts minimum
Skater categories: G, A, P, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP
Goalie categories: W, L, GAA, SV%, and SO

This is a supplemental draft. I have found myself with early back to back picks in this part of the draft. I usually do 1yr leagues, so I need a some keeper help.

What is the best keeper combo?
A: Malkin/Heatley
B: Malkin/Kane
C: Malkin/Green
D: Kane/Heatley
E: Other

[MacLiii]

1. Malkin
2. Getzlaf
3. Green
4. Rask
5. Halak
6. Kane
7. Heatley
8. Keith
9. Iginla
10. Brodeur
11. Vinny
12. Niemi

[mister_mcgoo]

Hey Gern, can you clarify a bit...is that your team and you're asking who to keep (top 4) or do you already have your keepers in and these are the options you can pick from?

thanks

[Gern Blansten]

Hey Gern, can you clarify a bit...is that your team and you're asking who to keep (top 4) or do you already have your keepers in and these are the options you can pick from?

thanks

Okay, I changed the OP.

To clarify, new league for me. Quasi complicated rules involving two divisions and moving in between them depending on how you do. I took over a team. I had the choice of keeping 1-4 players or none. If I chose none (which I did), I moved up my draft position in the supplemental draft. The guys in MacLiii's post are the best available guys.

I am curious on what you all think the order would be that they are taken. More acute, since I am on the clock right now, are my first two picks (B2B). Thus I changed the OP to clear it up a little.

Sorry for all the confusion!

[mister_mcgoo]

Malkin - Kane or Malkin Green...you also need to target a goalie asap...goalie cats are worth almost half and you start 3 per week, you gotta have top tenders to win this league

[Gern Blansten]

I gotta say I'm a bit surprised by the lack of love toward Heatley, especially being a LW along with the dual position in Yahoo. I agree on the goalie thing. The top guys are gone: Lu, Lundy, Bryz. Broduer is still available but old as dirt.

[rainydrinkwater]

I would, without hesitation take Malkin and Green...then do a happy dance.

[WildCard2180]

Malkin and Kane easily.

[Kickerz]

The only 2 to argue between with any credibility are"

Malkin and Green

Malkin and Kane

I know that draft records would point to Malking and Green, and I am among them. Defenders usually up 2/3 of what forwards do. You can do the math.

[Shoeless]

I would, without hesitation take Malkin and Green...then do a happy dance.

Yup me too. No contest as far as I am concerned.

[aj_ranger]

Malkin/Green for me too, far ahead of the other options.

[Gern Blansten]

Thanks all!