Crosby Traded, How Did I Do?

[Superchief]

I traded Crosby, Elliott, and a 2nd & 3rd in 2011 for:

Bryzgalov, Stastny, Turris, Quincey, Tarasenko.

Good, bad, or ugly?

My team now:

Steve Ott - Paul Statsny - Michael Grabnar
Kyle Okposo - Kyle Turris - Josh Bailey
Sean Bergenheim - Lee Stempniak - Blake Comeau
Raffi Torres - Brian Rolston - Tomas Holmstrom

Erik Johnson - Keith Ballard - D
Jack Johnson - PK Subban - D
Zbynek Michalek - Kyle Quincey - D

Ilya Bryzgalov - G
Ondrej Pavelec - G
BENCH
TJ Hensick - W
Fabian Brunnstrum - W
Andrew Ebbett - C/W
Ryan Potulny - W
Jannik Hansen - W
Rostislav Olesz - W
Shane O'Brien - D
Jack Hillen - D
Brian Lee - D
Andy Sutton - D
Dan Hamhuis - D

[Kickerz]

Sorry. I don't like it at all.

My last offer to acquire Crosby was:

Roberto Luongo, Martin St.Louis, Daniel Alfredsson, a waiver move, and a 1st round pick. It was rejected.

If you move Crosby, you want more. Even in a 1 year.

[Newcastle]

Pardon my language but that is one the biggest rapes Ive ever seen. Hopefully you made him lube up first.

[NYR9394]

If Tarasenko and Turris pan out, then this trade isn't so terrible. However, if they don't, you've got killed. Stastny is safely on the rise, but those other guys may not pan out. I also understand the need for goaltending given how bad it was before the trade, but I probably would have looked for more in both goaltending and wing help for Sid.

[Shake]

Next time come here to the forums on such a large trade and seek help...sorry man, but that is a very bad trade.

[rainydrinkwater]

I traded Crosby, Elliott, and a 2nd & 3rd in 2011 for:

Bryzgalov, Stastny, Turris, Quincey, Tarasenko.

Good, bad, or ugly?

Bad and ugly. Sorry, too many thigs have to go right with too many players here for this deal to be even close to even.

[Calimero]

Whoa, is this a joke or what?! You gave up Crosby + 2 high picks and that's all you got in return? I'm having a really hard time believing this.

[Paperclip]

I'm sorry, but that was a terrible trade.

[Dean Youngblood]

welp, the guys are correct here. BAD TRADE.

[rtstr]

haha ouch man.

[subcrazy]

Ya this is a bad trade, I gave up in one league kopitar/stamkos/enstrom and 1st rnd pick for crosby and e.johnson.

[Jer Bu]

I hope you were either looking for a funny reaction, or posting a trade that someone else called fair and you wanted to quickly prove to them why it was a stinker.

[Killer67]

Even if you took out all the other stuff you threw in, it's still a very bad trade.

[rabidprairiedog]

sorry superchief, but i think you'll have to now change your name to "super-chump". i'd like to know how the other GM convinced you to make this deal.

[NYR9394]

Listen Superchief, it's not the worst deal in the world. You did get a very much needed great goalie and a valuable young center. However, what's done is done at this point and you just need to look at what you can do in the future to build up your roster. Don't let everyone piling on with the same exact opinion get you down. You win some, you lose some. My suggestion is that the next time you get an offer or are thinking about making an offer, consult us first. As you can see, we've got no shortage of guys willing to give opinions around here. Hopefully they'll just be a little more positively constructed next time.