Oshie and Perron

[Crazynuck]

I currently own Giroux, Berglund, Hensick and am looking to try to get Oshie or Perron.
Are any of my prospects worth trading to get one of these two guys?
I like my 3 guys but i have heard good things about the other two.

[Dobber]

I like the three prospects you already own, but I think Oshie beats all three out by a hair. Perron would rank fifth on my personal list here. Yes, he\'s in the NHL and doing well, but I don\'t think he has any of their upside.
B)

[Crazynuck]

thanks dobber..... the owner of oshie doesn\'t like to trade so i think i\'ll take my chances on Perron.
my dman prospects are russell and kindl. aside from EJ,JJ and Letang what other prospects who do u recommend to take a chance on. preferable a prospect that had not played an NHL game yet.

[angus]

Carl Soderberg - BOS
Jack Skille - CHI
Kulemin - TOR

a few guys to go after who should be in the NHL next season.

[Fighting_Emu]

Dobber wrote:

I like the three prospects you already own, but I think Oshie beats all three out by a hair. Perron would rank fifth on my personal list here. Yes, he\'s in the NHL and doing well, but I don\'t think he has any of their upside.
B)

Oshie ahead of all 3? Very interesting... How far away is he from the big show?

[angus]

Oshie is NHL-ready NOW, but he wanted to play another year at NDak. He is going to be one of the best two-way forwards in the game, although I am not sure about his offensive upside (right now, I think he tops out as a consistent 70-80 point guy).

Plays a fearless game like JR from his \'Hawk days.

[Pete]

You\'re right Angus. Oshie was a lock to be the 3rd center of the Blues (he had an awesome camp BTW). But he go back to UND with Duncan and another \"veteran\" to win a Championship and to finish his medicine or something like that. The guy seems to be very intelligent.

BTW Angus, I had never hear the comparison with JR but a lot of guy compare him with Brind\'Amour.

[Crazynuck]

i\'m in a pts only keeper and a 70-80 pt player is easy to obtain. for my prospects i\'m looking for the player with the most upside.
Dobber is your prospect guide you projected the following upside and i drafted accordingly.

hensick 85
giroux 95
berglund 85+
oshie 80
perron (not in the guide,what do you project his upsaide at?)

for a pts only would Oshie still be the top pick?