Assuming you mean Andy Mcdonald, then no I wouldn't do this trade. McDonald I think is the best player in that deal and I wouldn't give him up for what your getting in return.
Team is in my signature. 12 team keeper league points only. I am in the middle of the pack but from 2-8 spot is very close. At the end of the year we drop 9 players. All players on roster play every night. No bench players.
Would you guys do this deal? My Macdonald for his Rafalski and Hornqvist.
c- Tavares, Aho, Drouin ,Schenn, RNH
lw - Toffoli, Pacioretty, M. Marchment, Rust, Vatrano
rw- Ovechkin, Kucherov, Tarasenko, Duchene, Zuccarello
d- Q. Hughes, Letang, Pietrangelo, Fowler, Hanafin, Matheson
g- Rittich, Saros
I.R. Guentzel
Rookies: Kulich, Lysell, Nazar, Simashev, Mintyukov
Drop 8 players at the end of the year. No maximum/minimum games played. All players in line up every night
Assuming you mean Andy Mcdonald, then no I wouldn't do this trade. McDonald I think is the best player in that deal and I wouldn't give him up for what your getting in return.
18 Team Keeper, H2H, Daily, 10 Keepers/Season
G,A,P,+/-,PIM,PPP,GWG,W,GAA,SV%,SHO
3C, 3LW, 3RW, 4D, 2G
C - Stamkos, Giroux, Tavares, Ribeiro,
LW - Booth, Chimera, Ruutu, Thornton
RW - Hudler, Hemsky, Alfredsson, McDonald
D - Edler, Carle, Visnovsky, Kuba, Faulk, Orlov
G - Pavelec, Ward
I don't think I would do it either
your C position isn't that strong and McDonald is by far your 2nd best Center.
Your RW IS a little weak, but your D is strong so you don't need Rafalski. If you want a deal, I would add another one of your D and try to get a solid RW.
Hornqvist isn't too special at the moment. And on Nashville....may not have a tremendous amount of upside
Team 1:
G, A, SOG, PPP, SOG, Hit, Blk, W, SV%, GAA, SO
C - Matthews, Crosby, Point, Seguin
LW - Miller, Tkachuk, Gaudreau, Kaprizov, Schenn
RW - Terry, Necas, Reinhart, Boeser
D - Hedman, Pionk, Hanifin, McNabb
G - Hellebyuck, Ullmark
IR - Wilson, Petry
Team 2:
G, A, PP, SOG, Hit, Blk, W, GAA, SV%,
C - Kopitar, Hischier, Rantane
LW - Panarin, Guentzel, RNH
RW - Marner, Kucherov, R. Smith
D - Makar, Hamilton, Heisknen, Dillon
G - Vasilevskiy, Hellebyuck, Ullmark
IR - Wilson, Aho, Theodore