Alfy+Giroux for Lidstrom or Gonchar

[duducks]

Update:
The guy with Lidstrom/Gonchar is looking for atleast 1 RW, and is building for a season or 2 from now. I have no real interest in keeping Dumont on my team, I drafted him hoping to be able to trade him for better than what was available at Defense at that point.

What sort of Dumont+ trade would you recomment I try to get either Gonch or Lindstrom? A 2 for 1 trade really benefits me, so I can grab a 3rd goalie off waivers.


Original Post below:
========================

The guy with Lidstrom and Gonchar is looking to rebuild, and both these dinosaurs have been made available. I think I can get Lidstrom for Alfredsson + Claude Giroux, and Gonchar would take a bit more.

Any ideas when Lidstrom/Gonchar/Alfy would be looking at retirement?
I'd say Alfy has 2-3 years left (2012/13 he'd only make $1mil, so i doubt he'd play that year) before retirement
Gonchar has to be done with Pittsburg after this year. he's 4 years younger than Lidstrom.

Thoughts on a trade?

[sexymountain]

DONT TRADE GIROUX. Hes gonna hit at least 60 this year and is gonna be hitting 80s in 2 years. Lidstroms will have 2 years at most and gonchar 3. Its not worth losing a stud like Giroux and ontop of that you lose Alfredsson.

[Nieuwendyk]

EDIT: Just saw that you had 2 Util. I change my mind, Alfy/Giroux for either D is not the most ideal move for you. Alfy should get at least 75+ and Giroux is great depth.

[duducks]

Is Dumont + Alf too much of a lowball offer?

[duducks]

updated Original post.
Looking for advice on a trade that gets me one of those Dmen, and gives up Dumont+