Trading H.Sedin + Theodore For Radulov + Richards

[jmammon]

I am in a 12-Team Keeper League. We keep 6 players with a limit of 2 goalies. We have a roster of 19 players and 1 IR spot. It is a Head-2-Head pool with the categories being:
G,A,P,PPP,+/-,PIM,GWG,
Goalies:
W,SO,GAA, SV %
An offer has been put onto the table and I think I should accept but I just want to confirm. The other owner wants to unite the Sedins.

To Me:
Radulov RW
Richards C

To Him:
D.Sedin LW
Theodore G (Currently IR-Able in our pool which allows you to carry one extra player)

I countered with a lesser deal but am starting to feel like I am crazy for not taking the original. Thoughts?



Here is my current roster:
C Michael Nylander (Was - C)
C Jarret Stoll (Edm - C)
LW Alexei Ponikarovsky (Tor - LW)
LW Paul Kariya (StL - LW)
RW Jaromir Jagr (NYR - RW)
RW Shane Doan (Pho - RW)
D Marc-Andre Bergeron (NYI - D)
D Jay Bouwmeester (Fla - D)
D --empty--
Util Daniel Sedin (Van - LW)
G Martin Gerber (Ott - G)
G Vesa Toskala (Tor - G)
BN Dainius Zubrus (NJ - RW)
BN Olli Jokinen (Fla - C)
BN Kristian Huselius (Cgy - LW)
BN Lee Stempniak (StL - RW)
BN David Legwand (Nsh - C)
BN Brad Boyes (StL - C)
BN Manny Legace (StL - G) DTD
BN Marc Denis (TB - G)
IR Jose Theodore (Col - G) IR

[mclarenf1]

if its brad richards definitely take it, if its mike, i\'d still take it.

its a keeper league and radulov is gold in keeper leagues, NSH is going to build around this guy and thats always a good sign and on top of that you get either b. richards who if he plays with the right players is an elite player and m. richards has a lot of potential on the young flyers.

you\'ll be giving up an injured goalie who everyone just hopes will become good (it\'ll take a lot of hoping) and a good player who plays on the defensive canucks which will limit his point scoring.

i would definitely take this deal.

[Shoeless]

You may be crazy for not taking the deal as offered, as it was certainly a good one for you - however this guy likely isn\'t going anywhere if he has his heart set on Sedin.

Given a second chance to accept I think I would.