Who to keep ? Cammalleri Boyes or Marleau

[towntoker]

I am only able to protect one of the three. pts only 1G=1pt 1A=1pt. Im thinking Marleau over Cammi but I would like to hear some opinions.
Thanks

[MXHockey]

Welcome to the site towntoker.

Does your league have positional requirements. It would be helpful if you list your league details including players and active roster requirements.....

Cheers.

[Dutch]

I would pick Cammy, but it\'s gonna be HUGE where he ends up with. If it\'s toronto, maybe keep marleau. Otherwise I would keep him. Boyes Might be an option depending on the rest of your roster. If you need rw more than anything, keep him.

Maybe give us a little more info in regards to what your team looks like

[towntoker]

No positional req. forwards are forwards. Thanks I am going to add my league details right now.

[The Hockey Hitman]

Boyes is my choice. Best goal scorer of the bunch, and playing for offensively loaded Blues squad. 2nd choice would be Cammalleri, but hes not my first choice because the uncertainty of where he lands this summer will affect his fantasy value.

[vandalay]

I would probably keep Cammy and Boyes over Marleau. Cammy is probably the top choice.

[MXHockey]

I would agree with above posters who have essentially widdled it down to a decision between Boyes and Cammy.

Marleau is your 3rd choice here.

Cammy has shown he can be a ppg player on two teams now, the Kings and the Flames. I think he\'ll be fine regardless where he ends up.

Age shouldn\'t be a factor here, as both Boyes and Cammy are 27yrs old.

It is possible that Boyes can out-point him, but at this point I would say go for the more proven guy here in Cammy.

Cheers.

[sexymountain]

Another vote for Cammi

[Zorro]

I think Marleau will get alot of his game back on a new team, if he gets traded. If he stays with SANJOSE you will have to wait another year.

Boyes is a good goal scorer and is very under-rated in my mind and is on a great young team, but sooner or later the scoring in St.Louis is going to be spread out over 2, probably 3 lines. They have alot of great young guys coming through the system so they will be like Chicago soon. Berglund and Oshie will be the top guys like Toews and Kane.

I really think I would take Cammalerri, I really think he has the goods and is the best point producer out of the three. I guess it all depends on where he goes but they are going to throw alot of money at him and I think will get alot of icetime wherever he goes..

Its a tough choice because Marleau is great and will do some good on a new team, Boyes is young and St.Louis is going to be great, but Cammalerri is points machine, he is always on the scoresheet.

This is just my opinion, hope a little bit of this helps. Goodluck with your decision.
Z..