Staal/Toskala for Miller/Horton

[chowder]

12 team H2H (4 keepers) I\'m team 1.

Team 1 needs some goalie help. Team 2 is the only team in the league with 3 good goalies. Team 2 could use another center. There are 2 more draft picks yet to come, there are no remotely decent goalies, and the best centers left are probably Connolly, M. Koivu, Pavelski, and Weight.

Who wins this one? This is what I\'m thinking of proposing.

E. Staal/Toskala for R. Miller/Horton (I don\'t even really want Horton I just figured it would make things even)

edit: I guess cats would help.
G, A, P, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, W, L, GAA, SV%, and SO

Consider these two rosters:

TEAM 1
------

C- E. Staal
C- O. Jokinen
LW- A. Tanguay
LW- R.Smyth
RW- JP.Dumont
RW- M.Knuble
UTL-S.Doan
D-S.Gonchar
D-J.Pitkanen
D-A.Meszaros
D-
G- V. Toskala
G- R.Dipietro
BN-O.Kolzig
BN-D.Roy
BN-M.Erat
BN-J.Toews
BN-

TEAM 2
------

C-P.Marleau
C-A.Mcdonald
LW-P.Kariya
LW-R.Nash
RW-J.Iginla
RW-M.Recchi
UTL-K.Huselius
D-B.Rafalski
D-MA Bergeron
D-C.Erhoff
D-
G-R.Miller
G-R.Luongo
BN-K.Lehtonen{G}
BN-N.Horton
BN-M.Satan
BN-L.Stempniak
BN-


Thanks

Post edited by: chowder, at: 2007/10/02 04:04

[Shoeless]

Based on need, you would win this - frankly I don\'t think he needs Staal for the price. On his side of the deal I don\'t see he gains much - he could do better.

[chowder]

he only has marleau, mcdonald, and horton at C. none of them are that great...certainly not keepers.

anything i could do to make it better for him, yet still worthwhile for me?

[Shoeless]

Right got you there and Staal racked up such a big year last year.

Yeah you could go Staal, Gonchar, Toskala for Miller, Horton, Rafalski - you are kinda not in the driver\'s seat on this deal as your need for a goaltender is so substantial - think likely you need to overpay.

You could try the first idea on him and see if he bites and if not then whistle back the second one - you will survive making this deal. Perhaps weep a little in the process.:P

Post edited by: Shoeless, at: 2007/10/02 04:39

[andrewklassen]

This reverse side of this trade offer is posted on another thread :P . TeeHee! You get to see both sides of the offer.

[The Good Sir]

Chowder are u trying to steal my alter ego???

[chowder]

Chowdeur wrote:

Chowder are u trying to steal my alter ego???

haha, been my nick for over 10 years