Malkin for Horton & Poulit

[Redlight]

Hey guys, Looking for some input who wins this trade, points only, with long term timeline in mind.

[bluejays]

Hands down - Malkin. He will be a 100 pointer year after year, and Horton tops out approx. 80. Playing with Crosby beats Jokinen, not to mention the studs on PP1 blueline - Whitney/Gonchar.

I think you also have to consider injuries. Horton has been a bit of a band-aid boy and plays a rough brand of hockey, thus more injury prone. Keep or get Malkin!

[Shoeless]

Redlight

Malkin vs Horton/Poulit

[typo88]

There is no real thought process here, grab malkin and run, if your giving up malkin, jsut run far far far far away from this trade.

[primeau25]

this isn\'t a question at ALL. MALKIN

versus

horton and pouliot!

[sakic19]

this shouldnt even be a topic, malkin easily.

[Enapai]

Think of it this way. Malkin consistently warants consideration for a 1st round pick. Whould you pick Pouloit or Horton in the first round? Obviously not. In fact in a one year yahoo draft I had on thursday I picked up Horton with the last pick in the entire draft. I have him in a keeper and got him in the 12th round.

Such a trade would be absurd.

[Redlight]

Thanks guys for solidifying my thoughts, I am the one trying to get Malkin, I thought he was going to do this deal, but I guess he found out this site and read the posts. His first offer was Malkin & Bernier for Horton & Michalek should I accept this deal?

[Nucks]

DO IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Pete]

Malkin by a MILE !

[Redlight]

Deal done, I got Malkin, thanks guys for the reassurance, next one my list is JJ.

[smoothfun]

you need to keep dealing with this guy , or send him over to my pool.very lop-sided in your favour.