Fantilli vs Stutzle

[flyers94]

What’s your best guess here… who has the better career? Will rep where I can

[RizzeeDizzee]

Non-scoring peripherals likely will be comparable, so it probably will come down to points. Stutzle has a "bird in hand" edge; and although it seems like he's taken a step back, he's been snakebit in terms of his SH% and on the PP. With Fantilli, there's always the possibility he doesn't live up to expectations, although early returns are promising. With Stutzle, there's also a good chance he gets winger eligibility, which, although you don't have FOW as a category, still gives you roster flexibility.

Given all this, I think I'm saying Stutzle. Or ask yourself this - if you owned Stutzle, would you trade him for Fantilli straight up? I don't think many - myself included - would do so, which says a lot.

[TheDard]

I would want Sutzle.

[Bubba55]

Stutzle for the next 2 maybe 3 years and then perhaps it's close. Or not, we'll see. Until Fantilli scores at a ppg pace which won't be any time soon IMO, I'll take the guy who's already been there and done that. I like Fantilli but the kids 19 years old and Stutzle is now a grizzled veteran at the age of 22. Fantilli has some catching up to do. It will very likely happen, but it will take some time and as Rizzee points out, a bird in the hand.

[zambronies]

Who can help you more in the next couple of seasons? Stutzle.

Who will have the better career? I think Fantilli may have more upside to his game, but it will take him a few seasons to see it.

I’d take Stutzle in a trade today as he’s the more ‘sure thing’ today. But to answer the question of who has a better career, I would take my chances on going against the grain and saying Fantilli will have the better career.

[Feenom]

Stutzle for me.

[jshed2]

Give me Stutzle. imo they have similar upside and Stutzle has already put up a 90 point season and is only 22. I'm taking the known quantity in a 22 year old 80-90 point player with 100 point upside over a 19 year old who has to prove his potential still with 105 upside. Not worth the risk for a relatively small difference in reward.