Makar vs Tkachuk

[Rhem]

Stats are: G,a, pts, +\-, ppp, shp, GWG, Pims, hits
2 of each forward position and one utl and one F and 4D
Who wins this deal? Roster doesn't matter. I currently have Makar

[chuckcouples]

Whoever gets Makar wins

[dejeanneret]

I'm not sure which Tkachuk you're talking about, but man I still think this is pretty close.

Makar is obviously the elite of the elite at D, but he gives next to nothing in the hits and PIMs department. Compared to Matthew T, who lights it up pretty much across the board, and Brady who's a little light on points and PPP compared to the other two, but makes up for it in hits and PIMs.

I can fairly easily talk myself into building around any of the three here. But I guess given roster requirements, I'd start with Makar and then go from there. Would honestly be tough for me to leave either Tkachuck behind though ... I love building banger league fantasy teams with multi-cat beasts at the outset.

[Rhem]

It's Brady T sorry

[senryu]

Depends on whether it is one year, short-term keeper, or long-term. In 1 year or a keeper for 2-3 more years, I'd prefer Brady T. in your scoring setup. Because big hitters and fighters tend to soften over time, Makar will hold his value longer than Brady T. will.

[Rhem]

It's a long term keeper.

- - - Updated - - -

It's keep 4. I have Mackinnon, Rantanen also.