Rank em for next year and beyond - REPs WIC

[finnys_fanatsy]

having some friendly banter and trade discussions on a few guys with a GM in my league. obviously everyone is partial to their own so i wanna invite some opinions with a rank 'em (tier them if its easier as we discussed alot of guys here)

His Squad
Guenther
Cozens
Perfetti
Keller
Rossi

My Squad
Norris
Batherson
Quinn
Suzuki


Couple of others id like to know where they land in this mess

Tippet
Farabee
KJohnson


i am NOT saying ALL of mine are better, and this was never an offer package all together, but different names tossed around in a few different options of a 4-6 player deal

[finnys_fanatsy]

Ok. I’ll start

Keller
Suz

Bath
Coz
Norris
Perf
Farabee
Tipp
Guenther
Rossi
KJo
Quinn

[Pengwin7]

I don't have any adjustments to your list.

From what I'm seeing... I'd probably actually push KJo and Quinn down into their own 3rd tier.
Both are just not showing *enough* to bump into their teams top6.

KJ... just looking very meh.
Quinn... just buried on that deep BUF F team

Depending on how linemates are clicking... any of that middle tier could rise to top... or bottom.
Tippett, IMO, is a "pure shooter" - so value depends on whether leagues have Goals and SOG boost/bonus.
His hockey IQ and passing is not good.
Farabee plays very well with high end talent (Couts, Konecny top line)... but I have some serious doubts that he could put up points if he got pushed to line 2/3.
i.e. I don't see him as a "play driver".

Norris is tough because he'll play 2nd fiddle to Stutzle for foreseeable future.

Perfetti showed nice game in first half...
But has been doghoused to 3rd/4th line and PP2 minutes with a healthy team, esp once Monahan was added.

His game is "there"...
But it doesn't seem WPG has faith in flexing him into top6 and PP1... yet.
He's going to have to nose-in-there... and I'm not sure if he can if all the top F (Scheif, Connor, Ehlers, Monahan) are healthy.
If WPG makes a run... Monahan will probably stick around... and that could be bad.

Tough one.
You definitely nailed the ranking.

You each have a "star" and a few "maybe stars, but probably 2nd liners and pp1/pp2 flex-ers" and one "ugh".

[Bubba55]

The only concern I have with the list is Norris. Hell of a player, but the dude has glass shoulders and that has cost him an awful lot of missed games and guess what, he looks to be seriously dinged up again and it's definitely a shoulder again even if the Sens won't admit it. IMO, his continuing "upper body" injuries are a huge concern that must be taken into consideration. So, he's behind Stutzle and he is making a very strong argument for Presidency of the Band Aid Boys. Based on pure skill he is likely ranked properly, however, the realities we just discussed, 2 C and frequently on IR suggest to me that he needs to moved down the list.