B.Tkachuk for Stutzle

[Christian T]

Yahoo Keep 3 + 2 Rookies 10 Team H2H

G, A, PPP, SOG, HITS, FOW, BLKS, W, GAA, SAVES, SV%

Have a bit of a keeper dilemma where I can only keep 3 of Miller, Pasta, Brady, Dobson and Demko/Shesterkin. Currently in 1st but have been offered Timmy Stu + 3rd for my Brady and a 6th for next year. I’d then keep some combo of Pasta, Miller and then either Dobson or Stu. We dropped from a Keep 5 to a keep 3, so the draft should be improved next year so I’m looking to acquire some picks at the expense of moving some of the guys that I couldn’t keep. Is this a decent deal to still keep me competitive the rest of the year and next year? Team in sig.

[senryu]

You can't trade Brady Tkachuk in this format for anything except McDavid.

[Axeman33]

To me, JT Miller, Pastrnak and BTkachuk are your keepers. If you do this deal, you are trading a keeper for someone isn't. A 3rd round pick is borderline insulting with a non-keeper coming in for a keeper going out.

Easy pass. I wont go as far as to say Tkachuk would only go out for someone like McDavid, but I am not trading a keeper in this format for anything less than another potential keeper and a top pick.

[Swarley]

I’d also pass on this deal

[TheDard]

As stated above by others; pass on this deal.

[RizzeeDizzee]

Tkachuk is very, very good in this format - make no mistake. But you don't count PIM, and he's downright lousy on the PP (10th most PP minutes over this season and the previous three, but only the 56th most PPPts). As such, I'm fairly confident his name value exceeds his actual value. I could see a universe where you'd package him as part of a deal for Makar, Hughes, MacKinnon, or Matthews.