M. Tkachuk/Q. Hughes for Rantenen/Hedman

[Hulke123]

Was offered Matthew Tkachuk/Quinn Hughes for Rantenen and Hedman. Thoughts?

The guy I'm chasing has Colorado guys, so it's tough with Rantenen so I kind of like the idea of loading up on Florida.

We start 2 RW, 2 C, 2 LW, 4 D, 2G

Current Lineup:
RW: Rantenen, Marner,
LW: Guentzel, Bertuzzi, Lehkonen
C: Zibenejad, Suzuki
C, RW: Duchene, Reinhart
C, LW: Huberdeau
D: Hedman, Dobson, Ekblad, Werenski, Slavin
G: Bobrovsky, Skinner, Jones, Husso (IR)

Scoring is:
G=3, A=2, +/-= 1, PPP=1, SHP=1, GWG=1
W=3, L=-1, SAVES= .2, SO=4, GA= -1

[Axeman33]

Seeing as there's not H+Bs in this league that helps Hughes' value but also hurts Tkachucks.

Last three years (I like to use an average)

Tkachuck has averaged 230pts in your setup
Hughes has averaged 187pts in your setup

An average of 417pts your getting in this offer

Rantanen has averaged 262pts
Hedman has averaged 164pts in your setup

An average of 426pts your giving up.

Long and short of it, that's the numbers on average looking at this year and the previous two calculated. Not much difference.

I'd do the deal simply based on the benefit of gaining 9 yrs on Hughes vs Hedman. You have to look at this year, but also beyond in keeper leagues.

[Swarley]

Good post by Axe, I agree with the break down and would do the deal.