David Rienbacher or Alexander Holtz

[Nylander]

Long term who do you guys prefer? G, A, Pts, SOG, Blks, Hits and Toi are cats in cats league.

Real sized NHL roster, 20 player minor system and 7 player bench.

Holtz is currently a minor streamer on my roster.

Would rather not post my team because I don’t really want team based bias simply looking for the better own in a vacuum.

I feel like personally Blks, Hits and Toi is a department where Rienbacher will really excel at but I must admit I don’t pay attention to either

[senryu]

I prefer Holtz. Holtz is on the cusp of NHL relevance. He's just behind a stacked top 6 in NJ. Reinbacher is years and years away from relevance. And even then, wasn't touted as a scorer; he's more of a overall defenseman. And this season, he hasn't been great.

Holtz is here, and just needs opportunity. Whether Reinbacher ever makes the NHL in a fantasy-meaningful way is in doubt.

[Belexus75]

while Reinbacher maybe very good contributor with those stat down the road..i think you looking at up to 5 years before he is as relevant in fantasy as Holtz already is...i also believe that Holtz will grow over next year or 2 and become 70 point player in the league.

[Nylander]

I prefer Holtz. Holtz is on the cusp of NHL relevance. He's just behind a stacked top 6 in NJ. Reinbacher is years and years away from relevance. And even then, wasn't touted as a scorer; he's more of a overall defenseman. And this season, he hasn't been great.

Holtz is here, and just needs opportunity. Whether Reinbacher ever makes the NHL in a fantasy-meaningful way is in doubt.

while Reinbacher maybe very good contributor with those stat down the road..i think you looking at up to 5 years before he is as relevant in fantasy as Holtz already is...i also believe that Holtz will grow over next year or 2 and become 70 point player in the league.

Thanks guys I’ll hold onto Holtz then.