Dobson offer

[MFantasy12]

Someone in my multi cats league send me this offer and I think its a great trade but Werenski worry me with his history of injuries

My
Dobson

vs

His

werenski and B.Clark

[LuigiC173]

no, doesn't move the needle enough, keep Noah.

[Feenom]

IF I had a crystal ball and was guaranteed a healthy Werenski then this is an easy accept. But with that uncertainty and Clarke yet to play in the NHL I would lean on keeping the real deal in Dobson.

[Swarley]

I’d keep Dobson

[Nylander]

I’d take the deal personally if Clarke doesn’t pan out you probably lose but if does then that’s a huge win

[senryu]

I like the Werenski Clarke side. Werenski's injury history is worrisome, but Clarke is in the top tier of d-man prospects with a very clear path to relevancy. I'd make the deal and then after Werenski has a solid 1/2 season or full season, send him away to someone else. Without the injury concerns, this would be a no brainer. I'd take the risk.

[MFantasy12]

I like the Werenski Clarke side. Werenski's injury history is worrisome, but Clarke is in the top tier of d-man prospects with a very clear path to relevancy. I'd make the deal and then after Werenski has a solid 1/2 season or full season, send him away to someone else. Without the injury concerns, this would be a no brainer. I'd take the risk.

Yeah, i think the same !

[4T2]

Dobson owner here… I’d definitely be tempted by this offer but I think I’m still keeping Noah. It’s close though

[CaveatEmptorer]

Werenski and clarke for me

[stevegamer]

I like the deal, and also the ida of moving off Werenski later.