Keller deal

[rtstr]

Which side?

Keller
vs
Wyatt Johnston + Matt Savoie

16 team full dynasty league, multicat (including faceoffs), goals worth slightly more than assists

[RizzeeDizzee]

Not an unfair deal for either side, but I'd take the bird in the hand in Keller unless I was rebuilding and needed more keepers, and even then I still might opt for Keller. Yes, Keller is not best at multicat but he is just starting to scratch the surface.

[Canucks_fan18]

Sounds like keep all? It's closer in that case bu Keller is looking like an 80 point player move forward. That's pretty high end. Were talking top 30 in the league for point production, I would need more than that to move a youngish asset who puts up those numbers.

[PenguinHunter]

I am keeping the Keller side.

I don't like the 2 for 1 trades when one player in not even guaranteed to ever play in the NHL.

[RizzeeDizzee]

I am keeping the Keller side.

I don't like the 2 for 1 trades when one player in not even guaranteed to ever play in the NHL.

Not to split hairs, but isn't Savoie with the Sabres as I write this?

[Feenom]

Keller side for me. He’s the straw that stirs that drink on the Yotes. WJ is a good player on a deep team. Same could be said for Savoie but haven’t seen him play.

[rtstr]

Thanks everyone for the replies. I am the Wyatt owner in this. I like Keller but I lean towards RizeeDizzee's analysis here - it's super close, and I think Wyatt's peripherals really raise his floor. Wyatt still seems chronically undervalued in fantasy circles. And for what it's worth, Savoie looks slated for L1 PP1 in his NHL debut tonight.

I sent the offer and it feels like a fair deal which is what you always want - now the other GM and I just need to see if it's time to pull the trigger. He has 4 Coyotes and needs to do something and loves Wyatt too.

[rtstr]

Update - other manager traded Keller+Perfetti+Walman for McTavish, which is, interesting.... so Wyatt+Savoie it is!