Campbell vs. Weber, Keeper league

[GMGates]

This was offered to me:

His Campbell: 2-7-9, +/- 6, 0 PIM

for

My Weber: 7-7-14, +/- 4, PIM 16

This is in a Head to Head Yahoo league where all the stats apply. Weber is on fire while Campbell is still trying to find it... Would you guys do this trade?

[woodrow]

Campbell I like and he just may outpoint Weber this year, although that may be a hard task to complete. Weber is 6+ years younger and will score many more goals. Campbell may have slightly higher upside and I like Chi going forward more than Nsh. Weber though is a multi-category stud who\'ll also get you plenty of PIMs.
I definitely keep my Weber.

[trouble]

Weber would be my choice...upside for points about the same, but he should score more and will get more PIM\'s, he\'s younger as well.

[GMGates]

Thanks guys! I guess you could say Weber is a poor man\'s Phaneuf! haha...

[NYR9394]

Weber is gonna be a monster. I\'d take him over Campbell.

[Atomic Wedgy]

I think there is a very good chance that Weber slows down a bit and Campbell ends up with more points. However, Weber\'s long term production will get you points in more scoring cats. I think he is a multi cat stud in the making. Campbell for this year, but Weber for the future.

[MXHockey]

Another vote for the Weber side.

[doulos]

I would also be taking Weber here because of what he has already done at such a young age.

[Shoeless]

I think Campbell is a converted figure skater actually. I really like Weber over him.

[Kid Tonka]

If pim count, Weber. Points only, Campbell.

[ridinryan44]

Agreed, only way I\'d take Campbell over Weber is points only. Funny, the only way I\'d take Campbell over a lot of Dmen is if it was points only!!!