I'd keep Demko, because he's generally been good the last couple years. Plus he gives volume, so a loss with lots of saves is palatable.
The other two are in tandems, and I think I prefer Skinner due to the Oilers being a better team.
Okay guys this needs an answer asap. My attached signature does not count for the league I'm talking about here. I play in a 3 keeper points league and my goalie situation is dire. With my second pick or (5th in the draft) I picked Demko and he has put up some nasty negative points and cost me a couple of weeks. I picked up Talbot and Skinner to play with Demko but can only keep 2 so I need to drop one. Who's gone.
Points are as follows: GP=1, W/L =3/-3, SO=5, GA=-3, SA=0.4
My thoughts have Demko turning it around eventually on a shitty defensive team. Talbot is number 1 but also on a shitty defensive team. Skinner has played great and if he can get 50/50 I think he's worth keeping even if the Oilers have a bad defensive team because they can score and win.
I'd keep Demko, because he's generally been good the last couple years. Plus he gives volume, so a loss with lots of saves is palatable.
The other two are in tandems, and I think I prefer Skinner due to the Oilers being a better team.
Want a Signature? Go to Settings, and you'll find Edit Signature down the list on the left.