****URGENT**** Would you make this trade? Rep if I can rep

[Stifler]

Hey all,

For POINTS ONLY, 1 year league

bit of an urgent trade question. Needs to be done in the next hour or 2 if it happens.

Huberdeau, Suzuki for Marner & 1 of Kreider/Kempe/lafreniere


Or would you do

Huberdeau, Suzuki, Krug for Marner, DeAngelo 7 1 of kreider/kempe/lafreniere



I don't like losing suzuki, but he won't accept any Hischier version unless he swaps his winger to Voracek which I don't like whatsoever.



Thanks for any quick input.

Rep where I can.

[finnys_fanatsy]

Hischier or HUberdeau?..

im holding if your moving Hubs AND Suzuki heer..

[Stifler]

Hischier or HUberdeau?..

im holding if your moving Hubs AND Suzuki heer..

no, Hischier would replace Suzuki in the deal.


I am the one moving HUberdeau.

I'm worried about his ice time dip, whereas Marner seems saFe for that.

[The Maritimer]

Of those wingers he is offering, Kreider is the only one paired with Marner that I would even remotely consider. Personally, I would actually prefer a Marner/Kreider combo to a Hubs/Suzuki... I think :/

[The Maritimer]

no, Hischier would replace Suzuki in the deal.


I am the one moving HUberdeau.

I'm worried about his ice time dip, whereas Marner seems saFe for that.

You're telling me you could move your Hubs/Hischier for his Marner/Kreider?!

[senryu]

If it is Huberdeau and Hischier for Marner and Kreider, I like the Marner/Kreider side. I still like the deal if Hischier is replaced by Suzuki.

[Atomic Wedgy]

Are you a Toronto fan perhaps? Just mentioning because maybe you have a bit of bias that is affecting your decision making. Personally, I dont like the deal for you. Huberdeau is the best player imo. I would not trade him.
Not sure why... might actually be my own bias here but I dont believe in Kreider. I have this nagging feeling he is Cheechoo in disguise.

[Stifler]

You're telling me you could move your Hubs/Hischier for his Marner/Kreider?!

no i would do that easily. He wants Huberdeau Suzuki for his Marner/kreider

- - - Updated - - -

Are you a Toronto fan perhaps? Just mentioning because maybe you have a bit of bias that is affecting your decision making. Personally, I dont like the deal for you. Huberdeau is the best player imo. I would not trade him.
Not sure why... might actually be my own bias here but I dont believe in Kreider. I have this nagging feeling he is Cheechoo in disguise.

no definitely not a Toronto fan.

Marner is RW, and his TOI is 4 or so minutes a game. Watching a few Flames games, Huberdeaus TOI has got me concerned at an alarming rate.

[Belexus75]

personally i dont care if its suzuki or heischier im taking Marner and Kreider here

[VintageVibe]

It's not an easy decision and a very fair swap.

Marner is my favourite player but I do think Huberdeau is the best standalone player in this deal. That said, hockey isn't a standalone game and you're right... his ice-time doesn't seem to be anywhere close to where it was when he put up 115 points last season. He could very well settle back down to ~85+ point territory unless things change for him TOI-wise.

I do think Suzuki takes another step this season as well and flirts with ~80+ points if he can stay healthy.

That said, I think the DeAngelo (~55+ points) part of the 2nd option swings this more into your favour as Krug is settling back down into the ~45 point zone on the back-end of his prime with Faulk and others eating away at his upside... and you're still getting ~95+ from Marner and ~70+ from Kreider (I firmly believe his 77 point season last year will end up being his career best).

End of day I'm counting ~220 points with Marner, Kreider, and DeAngelo vs. ~210 points from Huberdeau, Suzuki, Krug... +/- a 10-15 point swing on either side and assuming healthy seasons all around.

Good luck with your decision!

[Stifler]

allright fella's,

thanks for the responses


trade ended up being huberdeau and suzuki for marner and kreider.


not 100% convinced, but I do need a RW, and I had 1 too many C so positionally speaking it made sense.

Time will tell if it was smart

[The Maritimer]

allright fella's,

thanks for the responses


trade ended up being huberdeau and suzuki for marner and kreider.


not 100% convinced, but I do need a RW, and I had 1 too many C so positionally speaking it made sense.

Time will tell if it was smart

Congrats man. I think you made a good choice and I'm a Calgary fan. Lol

[Invictus]

Marner > Hubs
mark it