Newbie Needs help on ranking these players

[HockeyHank]

Offense + Defense Keeper League

Players who made NHL debut last season

Who will have the best career

Need help ranking these players 1-12. Thank You very much

Beniers

Boldy

Holtz

Jarvis

Lundell

Perfetti

Power

Power

Quinn

Raymond

Rossi

Seider

[random-d]

The difference between some of those players is splitting hairs and without specific criteria with which to differentiate many of them would be more or less equal. I would even go so far as to say that the only thing really separating most of them is experience and opportunity. You need to define some more specific evaluation criteria, otherwise this is just going to be a jumble of names with numbers next to them.

[Luffy D Monkey]

Best career, its very difficult to say. This is a list of blue chip prospects. Is it points only? Are defense more valuable to you than forwards?

Best career I'd project:

Tier 0 (elite talent)

Seider
Power

Tier 1 (already somewhat proven/surefire)

Raymond
Boldy
Beniers
Lundell
Jarvis

Tier 2 (unproven/could top the list but we have no idea yet)

Perfetti
Quinn

Tier 3 (longer odds)

Rossi
Holtz

[HockeyHank]

Thank You Luffy, I appreciate your input

[Belexus75]

i dont know what kind of league it is so cant really give you great analysis as to who is best for your settings but purely on offensive upside here are my rankings

1. Quinn
2. Boldy
3. Perfetti
4. Raymond
5. Holtz
6. Rossi
7. Lundell
8. Seider
9. Berniers
10. Jarvis
11. Power

Couple things here, first of all you have Power listed twice so there is actually 11 players to rank not 12

Second, obviously points from D are more curtail so you could move those D up a bit just based on that. However i dont see Power getting much of offensive opportunism for a while if ever so i would keep him at the bottom.

[HockeyHank]

Thank You Belexus

[Bubba55]

The difference between some of those players is splitting hairs and without specific criteria with which to differentiate many of them would be more or less equal. I would even go so far as to say that the only thing really separating most of them is experience and opportunity. You need to define some more specific evaluation criteria, otherwise this is just going to be a jumble of names with numbers next to them.

I have to agree with this. However, we do love to rank guys, so in a vacuum, understanding that these elite prospects are very very close:

1. Seider - For me he has to top the list based on what he did last season, a remarkable rookie campaign
2. Boldy
3. Perfetti
4. Raymond
5. Quinn
6. Rossi
7. Lundell
8. Holtz
9. Berniers
10. Jarvis
11. Power

[HockeyHank]

Thank You Bubba